top of page
396037-PCIIR1-401.jpg

SHUGAH COOKIE
BAKING CO.

Cakes | Cookies | Pies & Quiche | Rugelach

Preorder bakery, located on Siesta Drive in beautiful Sarasota, FL. Pick up your goodies by appointment only. Limited local delivery and shipping available. 


Our scrumptious American baked goods focus on New York & southern classics plus holiday traditions. 

We love working with individual customers and partner businesses to create sweet magic. Email us @info@shugahcookie.com to inquire about your celebrations, meetings and welcome amenities and custom corporate gifts. 


Home: Welcome
291978919_10228311035348893_1917141228850014966_n.jpg

PLAN YOUR SPECIAL EVENTS NOW!

Celebrations are sweeter with Shugah! 

We love celebrating your special occasions, including birthdays & anniversaries, parties of all kinds, showers & weddings of all sizes and corporate events.


All special event orders require a minimum of 4 weeks' notice.

Home: Quote

ALLERGY 
INFO

We use peanuts & tree nuts in some of our baking. While we sanitize carefully between baking projects, we are not a certified nut-free bakery and cannot guarantee a nut-free environment.

We use eggs, dairy, gluten and some soy products in most of our baking.

We offer some gluten-free bakery options using Cup4Cup Flour by Thomas Keller (Gluten-Free, Nut-Free, Kosher).

We are not a vegan or Kosher bakery.

Home: Text

HOW IT WORKS

Online Ordering:

Seasonal Menus are available via the Online Ordering tab on this website navigation bar.

Select what you like, choose your pickup or date/time and get your goodies by appointment at our location in midtown Sarasota. 

All Other Orders & Inquiries:

Text: 802.585.5131 or Email: info@shugahcookie.com. Orders are NOT CONFIRMED until you receive a reply and a prepayment request.

All orders require a minimum of 7 days lead time. Special Events require 1 month notice. 

Limited shipping available for rugelach and holiday menu items. Inquire within.

Email: info@shugahcookie.com

Text: 802.585.5131

Home: Hours
bottom of page